Transfer Pricing Review for Captives: How It Works

Transfer pricing has moved from a back-office concern to a board-level risk for captive owners. Tax authorities on both sides of the Atlantic are asking whether intra-group premiums are priced as two unrelated parties would have priced them, and recent cases show what happens when the answer is unclear: deductions challenged, profits reallocated, and in some cases penalties of up to 40 percent. That is why we added a Transfer Pricing Review to the Capitawise platform, alongside the captive scorecard, reserving, capital adequacy and surplus management tools our clients already use. This post explains how it works and why you can trust what it tells you.
How is the review built to show its working?
Putting a view on whether a premium is at arm's length is a sensitive thing to do. So we designed the review around one principle: it should earn your trust by showing its working, not by asking you to take its word. Four design choices make that possible.
- The facts and the opinion are kept separate — the review runs in two distinct stages. First, working only from your own data, it establishes the relevant facts about each line of coverage: the hard numbers that describe how that premium has behaved against its claims experience over time. This stage makes no judgement; it assembles the evidence. Only then does a second, separate stage form a view on what that evidence says. Keeping the two apart means you can always see the evidence on its own terms before any interpretation is layered on top.
- Every number is shown and traceable — nothing is a figure you have to accept on faith. Each one traces back to the underlying data it came from, so you or your advisor can see exactly where it originated and how it was arrived at. A tool that touches tax ought to be auditable by design, not a black box.
- The AI is kept on a short leash — the part that forms a view is deliberately boxed in. It can only reason about the evidence already put in front of it. It cannot invent figures or reach for conclusions the evidence does not support. What you get is a plain-English explanation and a simple at-a-glance signal, always in measured language and always pointing you towards a conversation with your advisor.
- It starts a conversation rather than ending one — the review shows where the evidence looks strong and where it looks thin, in language a non-specialist can follow, and leaves the specialist calls to the specialists.
Why does this matter now?
Courts have been consistent on one point: the outcome turns on evidence. In the US, the Tax Court's 2026 ruling in Jones v. Commissioner found premiums were not negotiated at arm's length and upheld 40 percent penalties. In Belgium, a 2025 Ghent Court judgment went the taxpayer's way, with advisers drawing the lesson that captive owners should have strong documentation ready. Either way, the captives that come through scrutiny well are the ones that can show their working on demand. The Transfer Pricing Review sits inside the same governed platform as your reserving, capital and surplus data, so your pricing evidence and your balance-sheet story stay consistent. If you want the capital-efficiency side of that story, our post on RAROC and capital-efficient investment covers how we think about return per unit of capital.
What is the review, and what is it not?
It is a structured, evidence-led read on how well your own loss experience supports the premium your captive charges, line of coverage by line of coverage, with the full calculation shown. It is not tax or legal advice, and it does not try to settle a question this nuanced on its own. It is the start of a well-informed conversation with your advisor, and the earlier you have that conversation, the more time you have to act.
If transfer pricing is on your agenda, we would welcome the chance to walk you through the review using your own data. Get in touch.
Tags
Sources
Frequently asked questions
What data does the review use?
Only your captive's own data. The first stage builds a factual picture for each line of coverage from that data alone — the hard numbers describing how each premium has behaved against its claims experience over time — before any interpretation is applied. No external benchmarks or pooled data are introduced; the evidence is yours and is shown on its own terms.
Can I see how a result was reached?
Yes. Every figure in the review is shown and traces back to the underlying data it came from, so you or your advisor can see exactly where it originated and how it was arrived at. A tool that touches tax should be auditable by design rather than a black box, so if something looks off you can check it rather than guess.
Does the AI make decisions for me?
No. The part of the review that forms a view is deliberately boxed in: it can only reason about the evidence already put in front of it, and it cannot invent figures or reach conclusions the evidence does not support. You get a plain-English explanation and an at-a-glance signal in measured language; the decisions stay with you and your advisors.
Does it replace my tax advisor?
No. The review is not tax or legal advice and does not try to settle a nuanced question on its own. It is designed to give you and your advisor a clearer, better-evidenced starting point for the conversation, line of coverage by line of coverage — and the earlier you have that conversation, the more time you have to act.
Last updated: November 13, 2026